jt: If you go to that site (Alabama GenWeb) which I furnished, click on "Clay County Cemetery Records" and then click on "Tomstone Project", you'll find 3 Shiloh cemeteries transcribed. It appears that one was the original but at some point relocated. See if this helps. Since the church doesn't have the records then you are kind of stuck with the transcription route unless you can go there in person and root around (lots of time involved with no guarantee of success). What exactly are you after, to confirm that someone is buried there or looking for birth/death dates or ........?