At that time, you knew the naturalization date and you were looking for the declaration of intention. Now you are asking for the naturalization petition, which is what you indicated you had back then. What do you actually have and what are you seeking to find?
In addition, this name is not found in the City Directory for the years 1884-1889 if that is what you were asking in your non-question.
For future information, sentences that have subjects and verbs and queries that have questions usually have a better chance of getting a response.