The first thing I see is that you have the first 5 people entered incorrectly.
,ADAMS Anna ,BUSH James ,GRIZZLE John ,WOODRING Albert ,ZIMMERMAN Elizabeth Adams, Anna Bush, James Grizzle, John Woodring, Albert Zimmerman, Elizabeth
The second five entries are correctly done. IE: ,ADAMS Anna should be as the second (Adams, Anna)
Get rid of the the incorrect entries and make sure the links are correct and still with the second set. You are showing (Adams, Anna) as one big last name in (ADAMS Anna). Match merge will have problems with that.