The 1861 has David as age 19, not 2. The one age 2 is Charles.
I suspected that the Eliza, age 21, is wife of James, age 24 and the children Charles 2, and Hugh 1, are their children. I went to 1871 to see if I could find James and Eliza
Where did you find the Farran's Point, Stormont references?
** I just found a tree which shows Charles Henry Cox, born April 25, 1859 to James M. Cox and Eliza Lennon - and shows them int he 1861 census I gave you.
tree shows Hamilton Hugh Cox born 1861 Canadawith same parents.
There are some photos etc. so why don't you email me and I can give you firstname.lastname@example.org
1851THURLOW, HASTINGS, CANADA WEST (ONTARIO)
Philip, age 50, farmer, born England
Mary, age 49, born England
Philip, age 27, laborer, born England
John, age 24, born England
Emily, age 16, born Canada
James, age 14, born Canada
Thomas, age 12, born Canada
David, age 10, born Canada
Maria, age 4,born Canada
The tree mentioned showed James in Michigan in 1870 so I took a look and it shows
1870 RIGA, LENAWEE, MICHIGAN
James, age 33, farmer, born Canada
Eliza, age 30,born Canada
Charles, age 11,born Canada
Hamilton, age 9, born Canada
James, age 5, born Canada
Robert, age 3, born MI
Thomas, age 1, born MI
on same page is a John Cox, age 42, born England, so right age to be brother of James
also next door to James and Eliza there is a Barney Lennon and family - Barney is age 28, born Canada so could be brother to Eliza
I was not able to find the marriage for James and Eliza for some reason.
I'm going to see if I can find anything more on Peter McSherry - died 1920.
I'm also interested in what you find on the village of Farran's Pt. as I have some Farran family and have never been able to figure them out - so wonder if Farran's Pt. was named after a Farran family - seems likely but who?