James Liberty was born in England about 1854. in 1884 he married my great grandmother Sarah Creighton in Mattawa, Ontario. They are listed in the 1891 census with there first 3 children in Revelstoke,BC.Sometime between then and 1901 Census they divorced and he is found listed as John Smith residing in New Westminster with all the children using the name of Smith. My Grandmother Ethel Harriet was married under that name. As they were listed as residing in New Westminster it is possible that the Thomas E you listed is their youngest son??