Hmm... Again the Patrick H. Boyle with a Reardon Boarder makes me more inclinded to think this Patrick belongs to my Boyle family BUT...it says he was born in IRE in 1859, and came to US in 1864. Patrick's sister Margaret married in 1864 in Boston, MA, so either she married shortly after arriving? came with only part of her fam?? On Michael Boyle's Petition for Citizenship; it states he arrived in the USA in 1848. And Applied for Citizenship in 1852. So Unless Michael came over on his own first and went back and forth a bit to visit the homestead and make more kids; not sure this is my Patrick? Also There is also a Patrick, Nora, Lizzie etc Boyle living with a Michael & Mary Boyle in Boston, MA in the 1860 census. So again either this is my Patrick and the census recorder or the person giving the census taker got the info wrong or this isn't my Patrick Boyle. :( (Scratches head) lol wish I had more to go on. Will run this by my other cousins and see what they think.