Hello. Found his death notice, it shows he died Jan 5, 1891 in Durham, New York. Perhaps a copy of his death certificate would yield more information about him. If it shows the cemetery, a copy of his interment record might also help you.
The Catskill NY Recorder Friday Jan 23, 1931 40 Years Ago Items from the Recorder, Jan 23, 1891 Died in Durham, Jan 5th, Cuyler Bogardus, aged sixty-two years.