The 1860 McHenry County Census, Algonquin Township has the following entry: PETTABONE, Amos; 35; M; Farmer; MA Lydia; 30; F; NY Ellen; 5; F; IL The Pettabone's are living with the following: PALMER, Phineas; 58; M; W; Farmer; 2000; 500; NY Ann; 61; F; MA
The 1870 McHenry County Census, Algonquin Township has the following entry: PETTIBONE, Amos; 45; M; W; Mass Lyddia; 39; F; W; New York Ellen; 16; F; W; Ill Anson; 1/12; M; W; Ill Living with them is: PALMER, Phinneas; 69; M; W; Retired Farmr; NY Anna; 71; F; W; Mass
There are also a few other Pettibone's living nearby. Could the PALMER's be Lydia Pettibone's parents?
In Crystal Lake, The Lake Avenue Cemetery (formerly known as the Crystal Lake Cemetery) has three Pettibone burials: PETTIBONE, C.; buried 2/14/1868 PETTIBONE, Elvira; 1827-1874 (wife of John) PETTIBONE, son of Amos; bur. 8/15/1868
Phineas and Anna PALMER are also buried in the Lake Avenue Cemetery: PALMER, Anna; d. 8/6/1884; 85 years old PALMER, Phineas S.; d. 7/7/1875; 74 years old