Caroline Clayton was living in Adair Co. IA with her grandfather, William Clayton in the 1880 census. She was the daughter of James Thomas (1845-1878)and Louisa Hodson (1848-1932)Clayton. She and her husband resided in Monmouth, IL in later years. Her sister Mary Elizabeth was my wifes ancester. Mary Elizabeth and her mother were living next door (next on the census) with Samuel Rolston and Parradine Rolston. Is this Parradine one of the Claytons? She does not seem to fit with Andrew or William's families. Mary Elizabeth Clayton married Levi Hovell in Avon, IL 1901.