Hi Melvyn Gibbs, I noticed a 2009 posting by you in which you said you didn't get email notification of a reply. The same still holds true - the Genforum notification system remains broken.
In that earlier post, you wrote, "My William Gibbs was born on 27th March 1847 in Clerkenwell, London. His father was William Gibbs (b: 12th April 1825 in Bethnal Green, London) and his mother was Eliza Britain (b: 12th May 1828 in Birmingham)...From what you said in your posting, your William may not be the same one as mine."
You can see from that experience that a precise birth day-month-year and place of birth may be necessary to distinguish one person from another. Your current query is very brief, and a little confusing as to who is who (for example, some of the names seem to refer to children of some of the other people). A couple of hours of research would be needed to clarify this family constellation - but perhaps you can do that quickly, given the research you've already done.
So, my recommendation to you is to say more about each individual and his/her relationship to the others.