Melissa, the Henry UTZ that was living in Blue River Township was born 29 Nov 1814 in Harrison Co. IN, to my g-g-g-grandparents Conrad and Elizabeth (BAKER) UTZ. He was probably named after his maternal grandfather, Henry BAKER. Henry married Sarah Berkshire in 1837, and he died 20 Feb. 1902. Based on their ages (Sarah was 44 in 1860), I doubt that they would have had a daughter in 1874.