Hi Michelle, I'm truly sorry, but I don't have anything that would help. My Mays came to US from Germany on the "Juventa" on June 19, 1854 and are descended from Frederick Kroft May. Your Mays were apparently already here. I thought searching for Smiths was tough until I tried a search engine for May. It hit on everyone born, married, or died in the month of May! Good Luck!