jeff: I saw your query and thought I would check and see what I could find out about your family. I'm not sure what you have. I found the census records from 1930 back to 1900, and a possible relationship in 1880 and further back.
The marriage of William W. Foley and Ella Baker was 5 Sep 1894 Madison co. IN
I believe His parents were William E. Foley and Delilah McIndoo who were married 26 Jan 1862 Owen Co. IN. The McIndoo family was in Owen County in 1860 and 1850. I also think his grandfathe was a William Foley b 1796 in New York, located in Owen Co. Indiana in 1860.
If any of this would be of help I can send it along. I am not related , but enjoy the hunt.