I looked up George Tyler on the 1850 Indiana census:
Hendricks County, Brown Twp, page 160
Tyler, George 50 KY Tyler, Martha J. 28 KY Tyler, Susan 19 IN Tyler, Preston 17 IN Tyler, Benjamin F. 15 IN Tyler, Lydia 11 IN Tyler, Charles 10 IN Tyler, Sarah 7 IN Tyler, George 5 IN Tyler, Melinda F. 1 IN Tyler, Alfred 6 IN
The age is a couple of years off, the state listed is Kentucky, and it appears that his wife must be deceased, so it's hard to tell if this is the correct family.However, it's the only George Tyler in Hendricks County.I have the 1850 census for the entire state, so I checked the other three George Tylers in the census, and none of them could be him.One was age 24 and the other two were teenagers.