Is this the George from the Pennsylvania WOLFE family that came through Ohio to Indiana? I have come across some references to them in my search for the WOLFE family in Sullivan, Shaker Prairie, Vigo, and Terre Haute among other places.
With the usual inspiration for names in that time period, I am not surprised that there are the same or similar names among the various families at the same relative time periods. In fact of Jacob's brothers and one of his nephews were named George. Common popular naming has caused some wrong turns and dead ends while doing research, I guess that is just one of the many things that makes genealogy so interesting.