Hello, saw your posting about Elizabeth Smith. I do know that Theophilus Padgett's son William A. Padgett (born in Indiana in 1833) married a Sarah Ellen Smith. One of her parents was born in Indiana and one in Ireland. They are in the 1880 Census and the 1870 census in Jefferson Township, Sullivan, Indiana, post office Carlisle. The 1870 doesn't seem to index properly but if you look for 'William Wrong' they are on the same page. (William 'Wrong' is William Long, my ancestor. Don't get me started!).
Good luck and let me know if you turn up anything,