Well, I believe your Jeremiah to be the Jeremiah A.Nevins age 8 born IND listed in the 1860 Vigo Co Otter Creek Twsp p.630 living with William Sullivan Engle age 26 IN and wife Talitha Caroline (Nevins) Engle age 20 IN
It would be my guess that Jeremiah is either a son or nephew of said Talitha
the 1850 Nevins Twsp. Vigo Co census p.120 has Wm.Nevans age 46 KY Mary (Biggs) Nevans age 45 KY Absalom B. age 19 IN Jeremiah A. age 17 IN Wm.H.H. age 14 IN Talitha C. age 13 IN
p.122 John Nevans age 12 IN
p.122 Absalom Nevans age 45? KY Angeline age 38 IN Mary E. age 12 IN Andrew W. age 10 IN Wm G. age 7 IN Eliza A. age 5 IN John P. age 1 IN
Both William and Absalom I believe are the children of Jeremiah Nevins whom Nevins Twsp is named after and grandchildren of Henry Nevins Sr. and Susan Marlin
my line is through Rev.David Marlin Nevins also a son of Henry Sr.
I would like for you to contact Betty Barrows Adams firstname.lastname@example.org is a first cousin of my grandfather and her husband I believe is descended from Jeremiah Nevins(son of Henry Sr.) she may be able to help you.