Sorry it took so long to get back to you and thank you for your help. I have done more reseaech since I last posted. I found Andrew J married to an Eliza Ann Mchaffie/Mchaffa 21 Oct 1858 in Clay Ind. He also could of married an Eliza Conley. One of their Children loretta(Retta) has a Eliza Conley listed her mother on the Indiana marriage collection 1800-1941 in I'm not sure which is the right Eliza or if he married twice. I believe I found Andrew's brother Joshua living in the same area. He was born 1832 in Tennesse. The 1880 census record indicate that Andrew's parents were born in Tennessee
I looked back at my records and for some reason I listed a Joshua or a John leonard as a possible father for Andrew. Joshua married Rhoda Sweet in Tennessee. Joshua and Johnwere living in Clay around 1830-40 but this is just a guess. There's a Joshua from 1850-1880 in Posey Clay but this Joshua is married to a Mary. There's a John Leonard born in Tennessee married to a Rhody in Des Moines, Polk, Iowa. Most of their children are born in Indiana but neither one of these two have children that match up with Andrew. It like trying to find a needle in a hay stack.