Mr. Freegrace Reynolds was in the congregation of Dr. West in Stockbridge. Dr. West died May 13, 1819, aged 84. From "Stockbridge, Past and Present; or Records of an Old Mission Station by Miss Electa F. Jones, published in Springfield by Samuel Bowles & Company 1854."
I just got back from Fort Wayne were I found the 1855 New York State Census in Greene County, New York with the following entries: Cox-2 41 REYNOLDS, Jacob frmr 70/35 DUT: Mariah[w] 58/35 GRE; Peter^ frmr 25, Andrew frmr 21, Andrew farmer 21. New-1 145 REYNOLDS, Jacob 1^btmn 39/9 ALB; Amelia M[w] 35/9 COL; ch: Abijah D 12 ALB, David 17, Mary F 2; o/r Elias S[brth]mrch 36/6 ALB; o/m Catherine OBRINE dmst 25/2m IRE
Orlando had a son Van Olinda or Olinde Sheffield Reynolds. And I have a brother whose middle name is Sheffield. Curiousity about this Sheffield Township in Berkshire County led me to Sheffield Congregational Church in Massachusetts.... "The Records of the Church of Christ in Sheffield" by James Bradford, Pastor, 1814 at Fort Wayne's library.