I think your best way to get information about Rev. Bailey's church would be to contact the local county genealogy societies to get some help.
You might also want to try to obtain an obit from the local newspaper. ---
Grand Traverse Area Genealogical Society P.O. Box 2015 Traverse City, Michigan 49685 Serving Northern Michigan counties: Antrim, Benzie, Grand Traverse, and Leelanau. --- Western Michigan Genealogical Society c/o Grand Rapids Public Library 111 Library Street NE Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503 Serving Western Michigan counties Muskegon, Newaygo, Montcalm, Ottawa, Kent, Ionia, Allegan and Barry --- 1860 Federal Census - Michigan > Leelanau > Crystal Lake > 1 Charles Bailey 38 M b. NY (Cong. M) Lucinda Bailey 35 Fb. Ohio Charles Bailey 10 M b. Ohio Mary E Bailey 32 F b. NY (maybe sister in law) Ida Bailey 7 F b. NY(Mary's daughter) --- 1870 Federal Census - Michigan > Benzie > Benzonia > 3 Charles Bailey 47 M W b. NY(Minister of the gospel) Lavinia Bailey 45 FW b. NY Charles Bailey 18 M W b. Ohio Caroline James 23 FW b. Penn (housekeeper) ------ BAILEY, CHARLES Date of death: 25-Jun-1878 White Married Man Age: 55 years (birth 1823) Cause of Death: Consumption Birthplace: New York Occupation: Farmer Father's Name: Bailey, Moses Father's Residence: New York Mother's Name: Bailey, Ester Mother's Residence: New York Date of record: 25-Jul-1879 Place of death: Alpine County of Death: Kent
I hope this information will be helpful to your research.