Thank You!! Thank You!!This looks like it could be him.Especially in 1880 with with the daughter, Rosana.He had one sister and her name was Rosina, name used in family.His mother and father were both born in NY too. YEAH!!! Now, would you have the 1910, by chance, he was in Battle Creek in 1911 when his father died.I will have to try and find out about his wifes family, did not know if he married, or who.This is the first great find!!!He might have been in NY still in 1870, with some other family?? Smith/Caswell/Randolph???Will check 1870 there.