These 3 Edson men and their families are all listed in the 1830 Niagara Co. Census as living in New Fane (now Newfane), in 1830. There was also a family of Nicholas Larkin living there about that time. Nicholas moved to PA, but left 2 or 3 sons living in New Fane, and I think that my anc. is one of these sons, and that he married Aurilla Edson ~1835, in NY or OH. I am supposing that she is a daughter of one of these 3 Edson men. I know she is not the daughter of Abijah, who also lived in Ontario Co., and the census does not show a child of her age for Nathaniel in that census, but James has a child the right age to have been her. I know that the father of Abijah was James, and that James had another son, named James, that was of the right age group to have been the James in New Fane in 1830. Do you know the relationship of these 3 men? Do you know the childrens names of Nathaniel and James?