Thank you for the info Thomas. I did find a census with the same as you sent. What is confusing is they list Catherine as widowed sister in law and Hezekiah as other. If Hezekiah was R.Philhower's son wouldn't they list him as is son rather than other. Kinda makes me wonder if Catherine's husband who died was Hezekiah's father and R. Philhower's brother. I'm new at this so maybe I'm looking into it a little to much.