Don't know if this will be of any help. Phebe's death record [5-8-1893]states b 1813 Dryden NY, [Tompkins Co], which was formed 1817 from Cayuga & Seneca Cos. Lewis d 1-30-1897....familysearch.org I noted on their tombstones full deathdate not given
TOMPKINS CO NY 1820 John MC FALL 120001-10001 1830 Henry MC FALL 101101-020001
1830 Groveland, Livingston NY Peter MC FALL ae 15-20, but there are a slew of feamles up to age 40-50. Livingston formed 1821 from Genesse & Ontario
Your families did not arrive together. Joshua TRAVIS was in Williams Co as early as 1838. Lewis Luce, I believe, was in Mercer Co PA 1840. Bartholomew GANNON was still in Groveland, Livingston Co NY 1850; d 12-2-1887 Seward NE
There is a Josh TRAVIS in Huron Co 1840, but if same person the age is off...b 1790-1800.
I found nothing in histories of Huron/Wms Cos for these folks.
If these ladies were sisters, they were sure spread far and wide.