I'm not sure if we are connected but it is possible. My Joseph Reese married a Mary "Polly" Young in 1831 (?). They lived in Putnam Co in 1840 and 1850 but they are listed on several Allen Co records during that time.They did finally settle in Bluffton in Allen Co.. He was born in 1800 in PA, not sure about her.
HAve you looked yet on the LDS familysearch.org site?I bet they've got some info for you.