I looked on Ancestry and found a good bit about a Charles Tidd, from the same area..a relative?and a couple daughters of Charles - Rebecca b1872 and Jary Jane,b 1874.Nothing much for Barber, other than the fact he was on several federal census and a marriage record with Mary A Harden 3-21-45. However, I found something different than what you cited...Ohio Marriages 1803-1900 say Wm Tidd married Sarah Brand 11-19-35 AND Cynthia Ann Martin 2-13-51. (Source Information: Jordan Dodd, Liahona Research. Ohio Marriages, 1803-1900 [database on-line].
There was also a David Sidd (perhaps Tidd) on the Mead twp, Belmont Co...1840 Fed Census.