Your Samuel was the son of an Elizabeth who was born in VA, and his father was born in PA.
On the 1850 Henry Co., IN census (August 16, 1850) page 279 502/502 Elizabeth Hutton - 69 - $300 - VA Samuel Hutton - 25 - book agent - OH
Living very near, the following gentleman.I did a search for him,and found his mother was born in VA and his father in PA, and one of his children in OH, prior to 1840, which was the time you said that they had moved to IN.
For me, I lean towards this being a much older brother of Samuel.He was very possibly the oldest child of Elizabeth, since he was also born in VA.
437/437 James Hutton - 47 - brick mason - $300 - VA Ann - 42 - VA Nancy - 15- OH William - 11 - IN Arthur - 9 - IN (From the LDS site I found: James Hutton md Ann Bishop before 1830 in Loudon Co., VA.She was born there on October 29,1809, and the record states that James was also born in Loudon Co.,VA.)