Candice:) Just as an FYI, Cuyahoga County boarders Geauga as do a few other counties. The Zip Code is the most important part of all this, it will indicate the county. We have the wackiest system I have ever seen. In the town I live in we have five different zip codes (its a small town). My mailing address is in Portage County, but I live in Geauga. But when I put in my zip code it comes up Geauga. If I just put in the Town it comes up Portage. I think it was done to confuse us searching for families. Anyway hope this helps for any future problems.