this is probably a very long shot but there is a John Newcomerliving in the 1860 census, Huron co., Greenfield twp. p.125 2127/1964 Charles Gordy/Goudy/Gondy? age 28 born OH Elizabethage 20 born PA John Newcomer age 20 born OH labor Perhaps he is a relative of yours???? Did your Mary have a sister named Elizabeth? Couldn't find this family in 1870 in same twp. Also did you know that Willard, Ohio used to be called Chicago Junction, Ohio?