Katreana: I have some of these people in my Ancestry.com family tree (Murphy Scott Family Tree). If you have access to it, you can compare the relationship.
I have all the Morgan County birth books, marriage books, death books and cemetery books that are in print. Here’s what I found:
-No mention of Wilbur Gheen. -No mention of Elmer Gheen. -In Mt. Olivet cemetery, there is a Jennie Gheen b: 06 May 1888,d:02 June 1888. In the cemetery book, she is listed near David W.and Elizabeth A. -In the Early Vital Records of Morgan County deaths book there is a Fanny May Gheen, d: 06 May 1888 at age 26 days (the print is fuzzy, but that is what it appears to be). She was born and resided in Hooksburg. Parents are not listed:( - In the Marriage book E, David W. (?) Gheen and Elizabeth Ann Miller were married on 12 June 1872. - In the Marriage book E, there is a David W. Lyne and Eliza J. Elliott married on 27 Dec 1876. Perhaps the source of discrepancy???
I cannot find another Morgan County marriage for David W. Gheen. I live/work near the Ohio Genealogy Society (OSG) – they have quite a bit on each Ohio county as well as each state. I go there often to do research. If you could provide me with any more info, I would be happy to pursue this mystery.