Not sure if I shared this with you. I called up the Greene County, PA genealogy team. They confirmed that there was a Catherine Chase born there in 1796. No record of her parents' names. There are also no records of Daniel. What stands out is that if she was born in 1796 (and this is the same Catherine that Daniel married) then she'd only be twelve years old when they were married in 1808. I am hoping 1808 is an estimate - for Catherine's sake!