Nancy-- Do you have any more information on the John M. Gibson who married Margaret Matilda Warner?
My gg-grandfather James William Gibson had a brother named John M. Gibson who was bornca. 1836 in (probably Belmont Co.) Ohio, and who lived in Beaver Twp., (first Guernsey then) Noble Co. for the 1850 and 1860 census records and then disappeared.He was married to a woman named Eliza in the 1860, but I have nothing further on him.
I would love to know if the John M. to whom you are referring might be the same as mine. --Kathryn Peters