I'm sure glad to met a Pryfogle researcher or at least someone collaterally interested in the Pryfogles.There aren't many of them.
Alex isn't my direct line either.Alexander's mother, Catherine Coulter, is the sister of my George W. Coulter.
The only disagreement I have with your data on Alexander is his place of birth.His Civil War pension file shows that he was born at Buck Run, Randolph County, IN.The pension file states that when he enlisted Alexander thought he was born in Illinois, but after returning home from the war his uncle, William Davis, told Alex that he was born in Buck Run, Randolph County, IN.
I think it's just a typo, but the twins were born in 1881, not 1887.
I sure would like to contact the descendants of Alex and Alice, if they are willing.I'm interested in what they know about the Pryfogle and Coulter families.I havealot of informaiton to share with them as well.