Stacey-Thanks for answering my posting. I sorta goofed anyway. Charles, Robert's father, died in 1885 in Richmond, In., he was b. in 1800. This family of Shaffers from Pa. settled in Huntington Co., In. William, Robert's brother, was my husband's g-grandfather. We have found the Shaffers to be very illusive. If Robert was born about 1826/27, and was in Preble co. in 1850, could some of his descendants have been the ones who crossed your Bunn line?