Becca, I show a James McFann, b-1834 OH that married Elisa, b-1840. They were married ca. 1858. This James is the son of David McFann and Catherine Scott. This is probably the James you are asking about. I have a "little" more info. if this is your James. I don't have Elisa's maiden name but it sounds like the right person if the dates are correct.