Carol, My grandmother was a Holsinger married to a Blevins so your post caught my eye. I also have Evans in my family line but have never sorted it all out.This is what I found on Ida Effie Evans.
1880 Nile Township, Scioto County census
David Evansage 44 husband Malissa Evansage 48 wife John A Evansage 17 Sarah E.B. Evans age 13 James M. Evansage 11 Charles W. Evans age 9 Genetta F. Evans age 7 Nancy A. Evansage 5 Rachel E. Evansage 4 Ide E. Evansage 1
Scioto County McKendree Cemetery listed as: Wife of Carry Lee Holsingerborn July 3,1879 died March 24,1907
Carry Lee Holsinger is also buried in the same cemetery. From the information in the census and the cemetery listing I would just about bet this is your Ida Effie Evans you are looking for.