I was running a quick check on some names in Scioto and was quite surprised to find your queries.I have a few odds and ends on T. J. McCollister, extracted when I was researching my Myres-Dalton-Coney lines in Portsmouth some years ago.I did not copy the newspaper name, just this first listing because it was so lovely:
"Maggie Shellieg married on Monday morning August 13 by Reverend Lovett Taft to Thomas McCollister, the Junior Editor of Portsmouth Republican...peace and plenty to them..."Newspaper of August 25, 1860
and the second because it was so poignant:
"Died in this city, Wednesday afternoon, the 3rd inst. of consumption, Maggie Shellieg, wife of T. J. McCollister and eldest daughter of William and Mary Shellieg..." Newspaper of December 6, 1862
William Shellieg was the second husband of my 4xgrandmother, Jane Dalton Myres Shellieg of Portsmouth and Covington, KY.