I only found for Samuel Custer in this family, in Trumbull co., OH.
I have the marriage license of Samuel Custer & Mary Ann Varnes, daughter of George Varnes and Susannah Pfouts.
QUIT CLAIM DEED: OH, Trumbull Co., 23 April 1850, Samuel purchased. Mary Ann's father died and Samuel Custer and Mary Ann Custer, his wife, inherited with her siblings the following:
"Quit Claim Deed; 23 April 1850, Susannah Varnes, widow of George Varnes; children named; "Susan Varnes execution of a certain release and quit claim to me by the grantees in this interment of a certain tract of lot of land therein described also the sum of one dollar received to my full satisfaction of Smith McFarland". Martin McMullen and Margaret McMullen, his wife, and Isaac Varnes have remised, released and forever quit claim... I, the said Susannah Varnes have wrought to have in or to right of dower"...
Judah Custer, brother, was m.,17 March 1857 in Elsworth,Mahoning Co., OH.
Joseph Custer, II, was m. 18 August 1861, Pymatuning Twp., Sharon, Mercer Co., PA.
But where were the other's married? Must have been Mercer Co., PA?