You must be suffering from the same bug that I have....It seems that these family mysteries become addictive....I can't tell you how much you have helped putting this family together. A little background, the Carlisle/Carlile line goes back to my grandmother, Exilva Florence Benner Knisley. She was a sister to Elmarta U. Benner who married Taylor Edward Carlisle. Elmarta & Taylor were the parents of William H.,Alta Marie, Benner H., John Nute, Mary, Charles, Lizzie & Nellie. When Elmarta died, Taylor returned to Ross County, Ohio & married Elmarta's sister, Roxie Marie. Benner Carlisle was one of my mother's favorite cousins and she talked of him often, thus I have been trying to learn more about him and his family. Again, thanks so much for the detective work you have performed for me.