Kelley,If you go to familysearch.org you will find a marriage for Effie Tracy and Charles Franklin Tubbs.
Michigan Marriages Groom-Chas. Franklin Tubbs Age-36 Parents-Albert Tubbs and Nettie Essner Bride-Effie Tracy Age-30 Father's Name-J. B. Tracy Marriage Place-Hart, Oceana, Michigan Marriage Date-Sept. 14, 1912
You will also find a marriage for Effie's sister Margaret Tracy to Thomas Twining.
Groom-Thomas A. Twining Age-30 Parents-William Twining and Eva Ebert Bride-Margaret Tracey Age-23 Birthplace-Walkerville, MI Parents-John B. Tracy and Julia Carr Marriage Place-Hart, Oceana, MI Marriage Date-July 12, 1906
1910 census for Leavitt, Oceana, Michigan (I think this is Paul Tracy) The last name is indexed as Lonenning but if you look at it I think it is Twining. Thomas A.Lonenning-age 34-born Michigan Margaret E. Lonenning-age 26-born Michigan Louis P. Sharp-nephew-age 9-born Wisconsin
If you go to google search archives you can find this
Ludington Daily News-July 8, 1938 Sunday and July 4 guests of Mr. and Mrs. Twining included Mr. and Mrs. Paul L. Tracy and daughter Joan of Akron, Ohio.
The Ludington Record-Dec. 31, 1896 On the evening of Dec. 24th a few intimate friends were present to witness the ceremony uniting in marriage Miss Lena Griswold and Mr. Myron Tracy.At 8 o'clock the bride and groom elect, with their attendants, Miss Ivah Throop, Miss Maggie Tracy, Messrs. Lou Griswold and Corliss Gifford, took their places under an arch of evergreens. Under the article there is a list of the presents-Paul's parents are mentioned. Water set-Charles and Effie Sharp.
Ludington Daily News-Mary 25, 1934 Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Twining entertained Mr. and Mrs. Arthur Tracy of Grand Rapids over the week-end of Mary 19.Mr. Tracy is a brother of Mrs. Twining. Charles Tubbs of Lansing who has been visiting at the Thomas Twining home, has gone to Ludington to visit relatives.
Ludington Daily News-Dec. 11, 1935 Mr. and Mrs. Marvin Tracy of Grand Rapids spent a few day recently with Mr. Tracy's sister, Mrs. Thomas Twining.
Ludington Daily News-April 29, 1949 Mrs. Thomas Twining, Mrs. E. L. Tubbs and Mrs. Ben Coolman were in Ludington recently.
Ludington Daily News-May 13, 1949 Mrs. E. L. Tubbs returned Saturday to Lansing after spending several weeks at the home of her brother-in-law and sister Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Twining.