On the 1870 Bloom Twp., Richland Co., Census, she is enumerated as "Sarah J.," 17, b. IN, in the household of James A. and Charlotte Jones.
On the 1860 Bloom Twp., Richland Co., she is enumerated as "Sarah," 8, b. IN, in the household of Isaac Fish, 27, Blacksmith, b. OH, and his wife, Charlotte, 26, also b. OH.
From the looks of the 1870 Census, it appears as though both Isaac Fish, as well as James A. Jones' first spouse, died prior to this census.By the ages (and surnames) of the children, some are Charlotte's (including Sarah) and NOT James', others are James' and NOT Charlotte's, and a couple are both James' and Charlotte's.
So then, with these censuses in retrospect:
Indiana Marriage Collection, 1800-1941
Name: Isaac Fish Spouse Name: Charlotte Brouhard Marriage Date: 26 Oct 1851 Marriage County: Boone Source Title 1: Boone County, Indiana Source Title 2: Index to Marriage Records 1844 - 1920 Inclusive Volume Source Title 3: W. P. A. Original Record Located: County Clerk's Office Book: C-2 OS Page: 239