Lee, I am sure we are still related, just maybe more distantly than you thought. There are too many coincidences. Maybe your Edgar was a much younger sibling of my George Abbott (father of Edgar and Belle), or a cousin. Names are passed down in families for generations, and I think there was probably a relative 1 or 2 generations further back that the Edgars and Belle were named for. In fact, since yours was Edgar Bell Abbott, I would look for a grandmother (great-grandmother) with the maiden name of Bell.