Mitchell, I had, at one time, that James Smithers Abercrombie was from the Abercrombie/Booth line. James Buford Abercrombie I think was the the son of Milo Bolling and Sarah Haden Abercrombie.(lost all my data during astorm) If you have access to the census look at Allen Abercrombie(David Allen?) in the 1870 Fannin County, TX. This may be a son of the James (abt 1785 SC) and Cynthia. It lists Allen Aber. 45 TX(?possible census mistake) Lucinda 47 SC, Washington 20 SC(?) and a Sarah Brown and her son?
1850 Talladaga County, AL. James Aber. 65 SC, Cynthia 55 SC, Lucinda 27 SC, David A.(David Allen?) 25 SC, Hast D. 24 SC, Bailes? 23 SC, Sarah 16 SC and Isabella 4(daughter of David and Lucinda?) Mississippi. Please let me know what you think of the Allen as a possible son of James and Cynthia. Also do you know Cynthias maiden? Pat Abercrombie(husband a decendent of Young David Abercrombie)