I agree completely with you about the Dial conclusions. But as I said I would have to see your research about a New Jersey connection. The Abercrombie in Penn. did not arrive in the colonies until the 1770's. This is the family General John Joseph descended from. One assumption you made which I believe is true is that Robert and James are related. But both families have worked on that, and there is no definite proof,unless you have found documents that no one else has found. We could just as well be decended from a William who arrived in Charlestown in 1685, I believe that was the date. I guess I need to see your proofs,Before I can say you are right or wrong.