Your John appears to be John William AGEE, son of John and Elizabeth (SMITH) AGEE. According to information that I was given by another Agee researcher, John William was b. 25 March, 1840, IN, and d. 18 June, 1919. He married Elizabeth MAUGHLER, 23 February, 1862. If that fits with your John W. AGEE, please contact me and I'll give you more information. Your John William AGEE would have been the nephew of my 3rd great-grandfather, William (Jarrett?) AGEE.