I realize you posted this almost 6 years ago, but I just found it and hope you're still monitoring this board, or it will send you an email after I post it.
I think your Eliza Jane (Aleshire) Bartley is related to my line. I have an Eliza Jane Aleshire who married Josheph Bartley sometime around 1832. You said her father was Charles Aleshire, born 1809, or did you mean Eliza Jane was born in 1809? If she was born in 1809, we have a match. I have some info on her descendants, but little on her ancestry.
I would appreciate knowing more if you have any more.