I have seen the songbook. My grandfather Joseph Addison Alewine and great-grandfather James G. W. Alewine were also ministers in those days and since we are also Alewines, though very distantly related, someone in the family kept it. I will check around to see if I can find it. But please don't get your hopes up, this is a long shot.
It was a small 5" by 8" paperback of 30 pages or so with a picture of Orion and I believe his family on the cover. It is probably the same picture that you already have. It was autographed.
- Bill Alewine
My great-great-great grandfather was Ephraim (abt 1797-aft 1860) son of Michael.