While cleaning out my parents house, we found a box in the attic of keepsakes of my grandmother, Martha Alewine.
Within this box, we found an old picture. Along the bottom is written "Joseph Alewine, Esq.". From the appearance and clothing, I am sure this is Joseph Alewine (1824-1885) who was married to Rebecca Lightsey.
I have uploaded a copy of the pic into my ancestry tree. If you cannot access it, please let me know.