The information in Alva Tuttle's book indicates that you have the names a bit scrambled.Here is John Tuttle's data:
JOHN TUTTLE, born 20-Feb-1726 in Lebanon, CT; son of John Tuttle born 1692 & Judith CHASE born ____; died ____ in Sunderland, MA.
Served in French & Indian Wars
Married on 17-Jul-1747 in Lebanon, CT, to Eunice ALLEN; baptised 17-Nov-1728 in Westerly, RI; daughter of Samuel Allen born ____ & Catherine MORRISON born ____; died in 1809.
Children of John & Eunice:
1.Lucy Tuttle, born 14-Feb-1748; 2.James Tuttle, born 25-feb-1749; 3.Lydia Tuttle, born c1752; 4.Ruth Tuttle, born 10-Jul-1754; married Nathan Rice; 5.Joseph Tuttle, born 31-Aug-1756; 6.Eunice Tuttle, born c1760; 7. John Tuttle, born 8-Apr-1763;