John D. Allen b 1850 NY and died 16 oct 1912 Huron MI. buried in Lucas OH.
Now there is no reason to suppose that your John really died before 1900 just because he was not in OHio in 1900. He could have been on a family trip to MI and then when his wife passed a way just stayed or even went back to MI and then was sent back to OH to be bured next to her or just because the kids wanted him where they lived. unfortunatly they did not list his parents on the death record.I have checked every thing on line that I can think of on death records and only found the one above that is even close to what you are looking for.